Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Galt's avatar

You speak of the body as a biological machine, and in this, you are correct: man is an organic entity. But you err profoundly when you describe consciousness as an "autonomic aberration" or a "fog of uncertainty."

​Reason is not a "functional consequence" of chemistry; it is a choice.

​Your view suggests that man is a victim of his own synapses, a prisoner of "illusory devils" and genetic programming. I reject this. Man is a being of self-made soul. While the brain is the organ of thought, the process of thought—the act of integration—is not automatic.

​You define discipline as the ability to choose suffering. I define it as the loyalty to one’s own conviction. Will is not the struggle to resist a "chemical urge"; it is the commitment to Reason as one's only absolute.

To claim we are "adrift to the whim of reactions" is to negate the very mind you use to form that argument. If your thoughts are merely chemical reactions, they have no claim to truth.

You speak of "martyrs" as proof of dignity. I tell you that dignity is found in the achievement of value, not in the sacrifice of it. A martyr who dies for a cause he does not rationally value is not a hero, but a victim of mysticism.

​You are correct that we must "exorcise" the influences of weakness. However, this is not done through "discipline" as a form of self-flagellation. It is done through Objectivity.

​"The man who lets a leader [or a chemical urge] prescribe his course is a parasite being led to the slaughter."

​The "devils" you describe are simply unfocused premises. When a man refuses to think, he becomes a pawn of his sub-conscious. To be free is to move from the level of percept (which we share with animals) to the level of concept (which is uniquely human).

​The "sea of reality" is not a chamber of horrors or a struggle of pain; it is a realm of infinite potential for the man who has the courage to perceive it as it is. Do not seek "absolution through abnegation." Seek triumph through productivity.

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?